For investors and historic home lovers alike, finding a property that balances original 1920s craftsmanship with strong rental metrics is a rare win. Located at 184 Wellington Ave, this sprawling 2,340-square-foot multi-family residence is listed at an accessible $140,000, offering a turnkey opportunity in one of Rochester’s classic residential pockets.
Intact Character and Smart Updates
Stepping inside, the home immediately showcases the heavy timber craftsmanship of the Craftsman era. Unlike many multi-family conversions that strip out historic character, this property has been beautifully preserved. Old-house enthusiasts will love:
Original Millwork: Rich, unpainted natural wood trim runs throughout the bright living spaces, providing a structural warmth you simply cannot replicate today.
Architectural Accents: Beautiful original pocket doors remain fully functional, alongside built-in cabinetry and a decorative fireplace that serves as an inviting focal point.
Refreshed Mechanicals: The heavy lifting has already been taken care of, featuring an 8-year-old roof, refreshed kitchens and bathrooms, and separate utilities for each unit—vastly simplifying property management.
Flexible Layout and Strong Metrics
With 4 bedrooms and 2 bathrooms split across its generous footprint, both units in this duplex are currently vacant and move-in ready. This makes the property an ideal candidate for an owner-occupant looking to “house hack” by living in one unit while letting a tenant pay the mortgage, or for an investor looking to place tenants immediately at market rate. With the average rent for a two-bedroom unit in the area sitting at $1,150 per month, the cash-flow potential here is undeniable.
Outside, a large, covered front porch offers the perfect neighborhood vantage point for morning coffee or warm summer evenings. Combining classic 1920 character, key structural updates, and exceptional value, this Wellington Avenue property is ready to anchor its next portfolio.
Zillow link https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/184-Wellington-Ave-Rochester-NY-14611/30880372_zpid/
Originating MLS: Rochester