Steeped in local history and architectural prominence, this 3,644-square-foot historic Tudor estate, constructed in 1880, is located at 417 Prospect St in Elkhart, Indiana (Zip Code 46514). Formerly the personal residence of Elkhart’s most renowned historic architect, E. Hill Turnock, this feature property is a celebrated staple on the city’s official architectural tours. Seamlessly merging meticulously preserved 145-year-old character with substantial mechanical modernizations, the multi-story mansion features five bedrooms, four bathrooms, and an extraordinarily flexible layout footprint.
The interior boasts exceptional vertical volume, anchored by towering 12-foot-plus ceilings and professionally refinished native hardwood floors on the main level. The home retains its rare, high-style woodwork, featuring soaring entryway arches, functional solid wood pocket doors, deep crown moldings, and original period hardware and hinges.
The estate is engineered with three separate staircases—including a specialized rear servant’s pass-through—creating an organic, intuitive flow through its 3,644 square feet. The grand main floor includes a warm reception foyer, an enclosed sunroom conservatory, a central great room centered around a grand fireplace, and a private executive library fully lined with original built-in bookshelves. The cooking core features an authentic, historic Coppes Kitchen assembly, elegantly bridging regional cabinet heritage with practical modern meal preparation.
The sleeping quarters are highly versatile and distributed intelligently across both levels:
Main Level: Hosts two complete bedroom chambers, including a spacious primary master suite with an attached half-bath, alongside a secondary main-floor bedroom featuring a full en-suite bathroom.
Upper Level: Accommodates three additional oversized bedrooms—including the historic secondary servant’s quarters complete with its own private, full en-suite bathroom. A newly renovated central family bathroom and an expansive upper parlor room (easily adaptable into a formal sixth bedroom) round out the top tier.
The estate is situated on a deep 0.38-acre (16,552-square-foot) village lot, featuring an attached two-car garage that provides secure vehicle shelter and extra workshop storage. The home has been completely painted and restored by professional preservationists. To provide complete transactional security and absolute peace of mind, the seller is including a full one-year home warranty policy alongside pre-inspection findings that have already been addressed.
📋 Property Specifications
💰 Price: $410,000
📍 Address: 417 Prospect St, Elkhart, IN 46514
📐 Interior Size: 3,644 sqft (Plus upper parlor flex space)
🌳 Lot Size: 0.38 Acres (16,552 sqft)
🛏️ Bedrooms: 5 (2 positioned on the main floor, 3 upstairs; expandable to 6)
🛁 Bathrooms: 4 (2 full en-suites, 1 newly renovated upper bath, 1 main-level half-bath)
🏗️ Year Built: 1880 (145 Years of Documented Provenance)
🎨 Heritage Status: Former home of architect E. Hill Turnock / Featured Architectural Tour Property
⚙️ Mechanical Infrastructure: Brand-new boiler system, tankless on-demand hot water heater, and water softener loop
🚗 Parking: Attached 2-car garage configuration
🛡️ Inclusions: 1-Year comprehensive home warranty + completed pre-inspection disclosures
🔍 Key Features & Preservation Details Explained
🏛️ Renowned Architect Provenance: Living in a home designed and inhabited by E. Hill Turnock places the owner in an elite class of preservation. Turnock’s signature style is felt through the soaring 12-foot ceilings, towering entryway transitions, and intricate molding reliefs that cannot be matched by modern production standards.
⚙️ Complete Heavy-Mechanical Upgrades: Bypassing the severe utility expenses that standardly shadow homes from the 1880s, the property features a brand-new high-efficiency boiler heating loop, a modern on-demand tankless hot water system, and a dedicated water softening unit.
🔄 Triple-Staircase Layout Isolation: The unique floor plan layout utilizes three independent stairwells, allowing a large family, multi-generational occupants, or guests to navigate between the main parlors and private upper quarters without disrupting centralized living spaces.
🪵 Historic Coppes Kitchen Architecture: The inclusion of an original Coppes kitchen celebrates Indiana’s premium built-in furniture history (famous for the “Napanee” concepts), offering collectors an incredibly rare, functional centerpiece of American craftsmanship.
🛏️ Masterful Main-Floor & Servant En-Suites: With two main-floor bedrooms and an upper-level servant flat featuring independent, private bathroom access, this property easily transitions into an upscale bed-and-breakfast canvas, an artist’s compound, or a high-end remote live-work estate.
📍 Premium St. Joseph River Corridor Setting: Located on Prospect Street, the estate sits in a highly historic residential neighborhood, keeping residents within quick driving lines of beautiful riverfront parks, downtown Elkhart’s dining district, local theaters, and regional commuter highways.
c
Zillow link https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/417-Prospect-St-Elkhart-IN-46514/50606473_zpid/
