623 W Milroy Ave: A Storybook 1893 Victorian in the Heart of Rensselaer

Experience one of the most admired residences in Indiana. Built in 1893, this magnificent 3-story Victorian at 623 W Milroy Ave is a rare intersection of Gilded Age craftsmanship and 21st-century sustainability. Situated on a sprawling 0.60-acre double lot and framed by a majestic black metal fence, this 3,771-square-foot treasure offers a lifestyle of “unforgettable charm.”

With a brand-new roof and a high-efficiency geothermal system, this estate is as practical as it is beautiful.

Property Investment Profile

• Price: $587,500

• Living Area: 3,771 sq. ft.

• Bedrooms: 5

• Bathrooms: 4 (3 Full, 1 Half)

• Lot Size: 0.60 Acres

• Major Upgrades: New Roof (Oct 2025) & Geothermal Heating/Cooling

Architectural Jewelry & Southern Traditions

From the moment you arrive, the home communicates a sense of protection and peace. The wide front porch features a ceiling painted “Haint Blue”—an old Southern tradition designed to ward off spirits and welcome good energy into the household.

Inside the 1893 Floor Plan:

• Masterful Woodwork: The interior is defined by inlaid hardwood floors and two sets of perfectly functioning original pocket doors.

• Triple-Threat Living: The main floor offers a rare three-room suite: a formal living room, an intimate parlor, and a private library.

• The Sun-Drenched Kitchen: A bright, window-wrapped kitchen features a cozy breakfast nook with a window seat, flowing seamlessly into the family room.

• The 2nd Story Sunroom: Perhaps the home’s most tranquil space, the second-floor sunroom offers elevated views of the mature treeline and manicured grounds.

Modern Sustainability: Geothermal & Low Taxes

Unlike many historic properties, 623 W Milroy Ave is optimized for low-cost, high-efficiency living:

• Geothermal HVAC: Enjoy the comfort of a consistent climate with a geothermal system—a high-capital upgrade that significantly reduces monthly utility bills.

• 2025 Roof: The roof was fully replaced in October 2025, providing decades of worry-free protection.

• Tax Benefit: The property benefits from Rensselaer’s low tax rates, making high-end living more affordable than in neighboring metropolitan hubs.

An Outdoor Oasis: Pool, Pond, and Play

The over half-acre lot is a private resort designed for multi-generational entertainment:

1. Recreation Deck: A large wooden deck anchors the swimming pool, perfect for summer gatherings.

2. Original Victorian Pond: A rare, preserved historical feature that connects the grounds back to the home’s 19th-century origin.

3. Evening Ambiance: A dedicated firepit area and a custom play fort ensure the backyard is utilized year-round.

From Zillow