Every so often, a property comes to market that completely captures the imagination. Situated on one of the most coveted, tree-lined streets in the Village of Spencerport, 135 Maplewood Ave is a picture-perfect English Cottage Tudor that effortlessly marries 1920s storybook romance with sophisticated modern luxury.
Offered at $299,900, this 1,915-square-foot residence sits proudly atop a rare, park-like 0.55-acre lot. It offers a quiet, serene sanctuary that feels entirely secluded, yet it is located just a half-mile—a scenic, 10-minute stroll—from both the historic Erie Canal and the local school campus.
Pristine 1920s Character
For fans of classic architectural millwork, the interior of this 1929 home is a masterclass in preservation. The home has been kept in pristine condition, showcasing design elements that define the craftsmanship of the era:
Rare Gumwood Trim: The main living spaces are framed by original, unpainted 1920s gumwood trim and doors, radiating a rich, honeyed warmth that cannot be replicated today.
The Cobblestone Hearth: A cozy den flows seamlessly off the main living room, anchored by a magnificent original cobblestone fireplace and flanked by custom built-in bookshelves.
Gleaming Hardwoods: The first floor features beautifully refinished original hardwood floors that catch the natural light pouring through a lovely formal dining room picture window.
A High-End Contemporary Transformation
While the architectural bones of the home honor its history, the current owners have spent the last five years executed a stunning, top-tier modernization of the home’s primary living spaces:
The Brand New Kitchen: The heart of the home is completely updated, featuring bright white shaker-style cabinetry, elegant quartz countertops, custom ceramic tile flooring, a breakfast bar for casual mornings, and a dedicated beverage center. To top it off, storage is never an issue thanks to a massive, walk-in pantry.
The Luxury Main Bath: The full bathroom has undergone a complete, down-to-the-studs remodel, offering a spa-like retreat with high-end fixtures and contemporary finishes.
Tucked-Away Private Quarters
The second level is designed for comfort and privacy. The primary bedroom suite serves as a true retreat, boasting a dedicated dressing area with original built-in drawers, an attached private powder room, and two rare, cedar-lined closets. The second and third bedrooms are equally spacious, offering rare, deep closet space that is hard to find in homes of this vintage.
Outside, the half-acre grounds unfurl into a sprawling green canvas. Framed by mature trees, the expansive backyard is ideal for summer entertaining, establishing heirloom gardens, or simply enjoying the peaceful village vibe.
With its fairytale exterior, impeccably maintained historic details, and turn-key modern amenities, this Maplewood Avenue landmark isn’t just a house—it’s a lifestyle. This is a rare chance to own a piece of Spencerport’s history, right where elegance and storybook charm meet.
\
