A Century of Hospitality in the Heart of America’s Favorite Village.
Step into the enchanting Thomas Walter Long House, a beautifully preserved 1893 Victorian landmark. For over 40 years, this property has flourished as a beloved Main Street Bed & Breakfast, famous for its exquisite gingerbread trim and unforgettable hospitality. Priced at $529,000, this is a rare opportunity to own a turnkey piece of Cooperstown history.
Authentic Victorian Elegance:
Period Details: Marvel at the stunning natural woodwork and elegant pocket doors that anchor the double living room—perfect for grand celebrations or cozy evenings.
Indoor-Outdoor Flow: The formal dining room opens to a vine-draped sitting porch, offering a magical setting for morning coffee or sunset cocktails.
Flexible Living: 4 spacious bedrooms and 5 bathrooms across three levels, including a delightful three-season retreat and a full attic with a den/studio and half bath.
Property & Outbuildings:
Historic Carriage Barn: The rear of the property features a massive two-story carriage barn with a two-car garage and a full upper level—ideal for a workshop, studio, or potential ADU expansion.
Garden Oasis: A peaceful, open backyard offers a private canvas for gardening, play, or upscale outdoor entertaining.
Unbeatable Cooperstown Location:
Situated in a prime “walk-to-everything” location, you are steps away from:
The National Baseball Hall of Fame
Otsego Lake & Glimmerglass State Park
The Fenimore Art Museum & Farmers’ Museum
Whether you wish to continue the legacy of a premier boutique inn or restore it as a majestic private residence, this lovingly maintained Victorian is ready for its next chapter.
🏛️ Beautifully Preserved Victorian | Built 1893
📍 202 Main St, Cooperstown, NY 13326
💰 $529,000
🛏️ 4 Bedrooms
🛁 5 Bathrooms
📐 2,232 Sq Ft
🌳 9,583 Sq Ft Lot
🍽️ Formerly the beloved Main Street B&B — welcoming guests for over 40 years
💖 Renowned for its unforgettable, indulgent breakfasts & loyal returning visitors
🎀 Stunning gingerbread trim & late-1800s Victorian charm
🪵 Original natural woodwork throughout
🚪 Elegant pocket doors in the double living room — perfect for gatherings
🍷 Dining room opens to a vine-draped sitting porch
☕ Magical spot for morning coffee or relaxed evenings
🛁 Main-level full bath, rear mudroom entry & extra pantry space
🌿 Charming enclosed three-season room
🛏️ Upper level features 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, plus a flexible bonus room
🪜 Stairway to a full attic with floored storage, half bath & space for a den or studio
🏗️ Full basement with abundant storage & workspace
🚗 Spacious two-story carriage barn
🚙 Two-car garage + upper level ideal for storage, workshop, or future expansion
🌸 Peaceful backyard ready for gardening, play, or outdoor entertaining
📍 Walk to Cooperstown’s most treasured attractions:
⚾ Baseball Hall of Fame
🌊 Otsego Lake
🌾 Fenimore Farm
🖼️ Fenimore Art Museum
📞 Listing by: DON OLIN REALTY INC
👤 Margaret Savoie
From Zillow
