Steeped in rich regional history and architectural significance, this 4,150-square-foot Prairie-style historic estate, constructed in 1916, is located at 905 N 2nd St in Arkansas City, Kansas (Zip Code 67005). The home was custom-built by its original namesake, Anthony Carlton—an Osage Native and prominent former tribal councilman. Spanning 4,150 square feet of meticulously preserved and updated interior living space, this four-bedroom, four-bathroom residence sits on an oversized 0.34-acre lot and seamlessly pairs early 20th-century craftsmanship with a substantial list of high-value mechanical modernizations and an independent, income-producing guest suite.
The main level serves as an elegant introduction to the estate’s Prairie-school architecture, boasting broad horizontal lines and an open room flow anchored by professionally refinished native hardwood floors. The ground floor features an expansive living room, a formal dining hall, a fully refreshed kitchen, and an attached conservatory sunroom warmed by a cozy integrated fireplace insert. The kitchen is highly functional, updated with contemporary cabinetry adjustments, fresh custom window treatments, a newer refrigerator (installed 2024), and a brand-new convection oven (installed 2025).
The upper residential level accommodates the primary bedroom chambers, featuring newly renovated full bathrooms outfitted with upgraded tiling and premium fixtures. To maximize comfort for a growing household, a brand-new second-floor bathroom suite was recently added to the layout, alongside a dedicated upper-level air conditioning system to ensure climate control during warmer summer months.
💵 Dual-Stream Income & Flex Space Potential
A standout asset of the Carlton Estate is its exceptional layout versatility, offering two independent spaces that can serve as premium multi-generational quarters or monthly income-generating rental units:
The Transformed Subterranean Suite: The basement tier has been fully converted into an autonomous, comfortable living apartment. Equipped with its own private layout, updated cozy finishes, and a brand-new dedicated bathroom, it serves as an ideal long-term tenant rental or private guest flat.
The Remodeled Detached Carriage House: Stepping out to the grounds, the standalone historic carriage house has undergone a comprehensive, top-to-bottom structural remodel, offering a pristine outbuilding canvas for a remote executive office, creative artisan loft, or an additional short-term rental asset.
📋 Property Specifications
💰 Price: $299,999
📍 Address: 905 N 2nd St, Arkansas City, KS 67005
📐 Interior Size: 4,150 sqft (Including fully finished income basement)
🌳 Lot Size: 0.34 Acres (14,810 sqft / Deep village parcel)
🛏️ Bedrooms: 4
🛁 Bathrooms: 4 Full (Including newly added second-story bath and new basement bath)
🏗️ Year Built: 1916
🏛️ Provenance: Historic Prairie-Style home built by Osage Tribal Councilman Anthony Carlton
🏠 Major Envelope Updates: Brand-new concrete tile roofs on both structures (March 2026); New sunroom flat roof & gutter guards (2026)
⚙️ Core Utilities: New hot water heater (2025), new sump pump (2025), added upstairs AC unit, and integrated water softener
🎨 Finishes: Historically inspired interior/exterior paint layers, refinished hardwoods, and new window treatments
🔍 Key Features & Investment Potential Explained
🏛️ Historic Prairie School Craftsmanship: Spanning over 4,100 square feet, the 1916 framing showcases the architectural integrity of the Anthony Carlton era. The broad windows, solid timber transitions, and stately presence offer a level of historical provenance highly sought after by preservationists.
🧱 Lifetime Concrete Tile Roofing Asset: The installation of matching concrete tile roofs across both the main house and carriage house represents an elite tier of exterior protection, shielding the buyer from the five-figure roofing liabilities typical of historic properties.
📈 Turnkey Subterranean Revenue Stream: With a fully finished basement flat boasting independent bathroom facilities and comfortable egress, an incoming owner can immediately house hack the property to significantly offset their monthly mortgage baseline.
🔌 Powered Outdoor Entertainment Pavilion: The backyard landscape goes beyond a simple lawn, integrating a custom-constructed garden lounge with direct electrical line tie-ins to support outdoor televisions, sound systems, and catering equipment.
🛡️ Total Infrastructure Peace of Mind: Armed with a new hot water network, specialized water softener, secondary upper AC handlers, and active basement water mitigation lines, the home drives modern efficiency inside a 110-year-old historic envelope.
📍 Strategic Cowley County Location: Situated on North 2nd Street, residents enjoy a peaceful neighborhood setting with quick transit lines to local public schools, historic downtown shopping corridors, regional parks along the Arkansas and Walnut rivers, and primary commuter highways.
Zillow link https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/905-N-2nd-St-Arkansas-City-KS-67005/77174164_zpid/